Guest Post – How to determine if the trend is your friend

This is a guest post that I thought would be of interest to my readers. Please read below to find out more about the author. (Note I have no affiliation with the below author / business).

About the author:

Lawrence Lam is the Managing Director & Founder of Lumenary, a fund that uncovers the best founder-led companies in the world. We invest in unique, overlooked companies in markets and industries beyond most managers’ reach. We are a different type of global fund – for more articles and information about us, visit www.lumenaryinvest.com

How to determine if the trend is your friend

At a recent lunch with another fund manager I found myself engaged in a discussion about the state of the current market.

            ‘From your perspective, are you seeing many good opportunities?’ I asked.

            ‘I’m seeing good companies, but prices are toppy,’ he said, wincing before continuing. ‘More than I’d like to pay. But we’ve recently deployed more anyway.’ He shrugged his shoulders, ‘Momentum in the market is strong – the fed is decreasing rates. Despite the high prices, we wouldn’t want to miss this momentum.’

            I nodded as we both acknowledged this unique investment environment. Decreasing rates, high stock valuations, yet stock prices that have continued to climb steadily.

Walking back to my office I reflected. ‘Is now a good time to be a momentum investor? Or is it time to go against the herd?’

Harness the power of momentum or be a contrarian?

It’s a dichotomy faced by all investors, but it isn’t a binary decision. Your portfolio can be made up of both momentum and contrarian investments. So the question becomes: how can we determine the optimal proportion of holdings between momentum and contrarian?

Are you seeing the full picture?

Momentum investors have much to gain if the wave of popularity is caught early. However, be the last one to the party and you will be left with all the cleaning up. The real question is: how much more of the wave is left to catch? The solution to this contradiction can be found by understanding the long-term context.

The ratio of a company’s stock price-to-intrinsic value tells us how much the market is willing to pay for the company. It’s a useful measurement of sentiment at one point in time. There’s a clear link between sentiment (the stock price) versus fundamental value (intrinsic value).

But it doesn’t give us the full picture. To understand this contradiction, we need to see how sentiment for the stock has changed over a significant period of time – over entire market cycles. Extend the ratio of stock price-to-intrinsic value over a 15 year horizon and you’ll now gain a multi-dimensional view of just how manic-depressive Mr Market is.

As an example, here is the change in sentiment for the founder-led aerospace electronics company HEICO Corporation.

During the GFC, Mr Market was very pessimistic. He was only willing to pay 1.8x the intrinsic value of HEICO. But alas Mr Market is as fickle as they come. More recently, he has been very bullish. He’s willing to pay 4.8x intrinsic value. A large proportion of the returns have been driven solely by the company’s increasing popularity with investors.

Now we have a better view of the context. Understanding the stock price and intrinsic value over a long time period equips us to answer the following question…

Is the party getting started or is it about to end?

There’s an interesting observation about parties. When do they end?

Answer? They end when the alcohol runs out. Rarely do they end immediately though. Good times roll on for a while longer before the sudden realisation hits the sobering crowd.

So when is the worst time to join a party?

As you’re pondering the answer, here is another view of HEICO to illustrate the point.

Although the intrinsic value of HEICO’s business has consistently increased over time, the increase in it’s price has far outpaced the fundamental growth of the company. HEICO is a solid and growing company, but its impressive performance has been driven primarily by sentiment and price, rather than actual business value. The price-to-intrinsic value ratio shows this.

Risk is heightened when a company’s stock price outpaces its intrinsic value for significant periods of time. As crazy as Mr Market is, one thing is certain – his enthusiasm and pessimism never last forever. The gravitational pull of a company’s fundamental value is unrelenting.

The best time to join a party is when there’s plenty of alcohol and not too many people. But tread carefully when there crowd is pumping and booze is running low. Whilst the fun may continue for a while longer yet, the risk of an abrupt ending is heightened.

A ‘reasonable’ price

Pure momentum investing focuses predominantly on the historical price movement and pays little attention to actual fundamental value. But if you want to understand if a trend is justified, the fundamentals are critical.

Armed with this insight, we can make a judgement call on what a ‘reasonable’ price would be and whether we should join the party. Some sectors run hot. Today, technology is a classic example. But a strong trend shouldn’t be a deterrent. Prices may seem exorbitant, but in the context of the company’s historical sentiment, sometimes the high price is worth paying. What may seem expensive on an absolute basis may be reasonable in the context of history. For example, the price-to-intrinsic value of Facebook was high on an absolute basis in late 2018, but was reasonable when compared to its history. It has proven to be a good entry point so far.

But there’s more for enterprising investors – the picture is still not yet complete.

A deeper level of analysis

Competition

You may have noticed my focus on individual company analysis rather than broad-based economic generalisations. We are buying slices of companies after all. Whilst we can understand the sentiment in our target company, it is also important to have context across other comparable companies. The same price-to-intrinsic value historical ratio across a few companies will give us a sense of sentiment across the sector. We’ll be able to see if there are any other reasonably priced companies.

Potential growth

So far the focus has been on gaining historical context. Sometimes the momentum is justified if there are tangible growth prospects. In other words, intrinsic value is expected to grow significantly with price. In those situations, the trend may be your friend. For those that heard me speak at the AIA National Conference, I outlined my framework to assess the potential growth of a company. 

Intrinsic value

Speculators focus on stock price movements only. Investors focus on the underlying true worth of a company.

As Warren Buffett says “Price is what you pay, value is what you get”.

The fundamentals of a company’s value is reflected in its Intrinsic value. Importantly, in determining a company’s intrinsic value, I’ve stripped out accounting distortions that may hide a company’s true worth.

Closing remarks

Is the trend your friend?

If the fundamentals of a company are sound and the price is reasonable in the context of its history and other competitors, then the trend may indeed be an ally. Ride the wave and enjoy the party.

Price and intrinsic value may deviate for many years but price will eventually move towards intrinsic value over the long-term. Seeing the full picture is key to capturing sensible opportunities. In every party, everyone sobers eventually.

Happy compounding.

Note:

Stocks mentioned have been used as examples only. They are not recommendations to buy or sell.

About Lawrence Lam

Lawrence Lam is the Managing Director & Founder of Lumenary, a fund that uncovers the best founder-led companies in the world. We invest in unique, overlooked companies in markets and industries beyond most managers’ reach. We are a different type of global fund – for more articles and information about us, visit www.lumenaryinvest.com

One thought on “Guest Post – How to determine if the trend is your friend”

  1. If you enjoyed the article, I would like to invite you to our three upcoming seminars where I discuss some very pertinent topics given today’s uncertain investing environment. These seminars are open to Wholesale/Sophisticated Investors only so please email invest@lumenaryinvest.com to register your interest.

    1. Investing in these uncertain times (Melbourne)
    Global geopolitical unrest, negative interest rates, and the emergence of nimble digital companies has led to an uncertain investment landscape. Yet the need to invest intelligently has never been more important. It is during these uncertain times that the enterprising investor can make money.

    The question is – how can investors navigate this volatile and uncertain environment to grow wealth over the long-term?

    For this event, I’ve partnered with Robert Gregory, Portfolio Manager & Founder of Glenmore Asset Management. Robert will be presenting from an Australian equities perspective, and I will discuss the global equities perspective.

    Location: Melbourne, Australia
    Date: Thurs, 31 October 2019

    2. Rethinking Blue Chip Investing (Melbourne)
    In this digital era, many blue chip companies have been challenged by emerging competitors. This ever-changing business landscape has made predicting long-term winners even harder for investors. Past blue chip investing rules no longer apply to the future. Investors looking for safe and long-term compounding stocks need to evolve their analysis.

    So how can investors find the next generation of emerging blue chip companies of tomorrow?
    What techniques can investors use to judge the growth potential of companies?

    Location: Melbourne, Australia
    Date: Thurs, 28 November 2019

    3. Rethinking Blue Chip Investing (Perth) [To be confirmed based on registrations]
    I’ve received some interest in Perth so I would like to see if we have enough attendees to launch an event in Perth. The topic will be the same as above.

    If you are interested in attending a Perth-based seminar, please register your interest below. We will update you with the final details of our Perth seminar once confirmed.

    Location: Perth, Australia
    Date: Tues, 22 October 2019

Leave a Reply